1. Introduction to Federalism
Federalism is a system of government where power is divided between a central (national) authority and various regional (state) authorities. The Constitution of India creates a federal structure to manage the country’s vast diversity, by ensuring that both the central government and the state governments share power and responsibilities.
India is a federal country with a unitary bias. While the Constitution establishes a federal system, it is designed to ensure the unity and integrity of the nation, which often leads to a stronger central government.
2. Key Features of Federalism in India
India follows a dual polity system, consisting of the Union (Central) Government and the State Governments. The division of powers is outlined in the Constitution of India.
i. Written Constitution
India has a written Constitution, which clearly defines the distribution of powers between the Union and the States. The Constitution acts as the supreme law, and all laws must comply with it.
ii. Division of Powers
The powers and responsibilities between the Union and the States are divided under three lists:
- Union List:
- Contains subjects on which only the Union Government can legislate.
- Examples: Defense, Foreign Affairs, Banking, Atomic Energy, Railways.
- State List:
- Contains subjects on which only the State Governments can legislate.
- Examples: Police, Public Health, Agriculture, Local Government.
- Concurrent List:
- Contains subjects on which both the Union and State Governments can legislate.
- Examples: Education, Marriage and Divorce, Criminal Law, Trade Unions.
In case of a conflict between Union and State laws on any matter in the Concurrent List, the Union law prevails.
iii. Supremacy of the Constitution
The Constitution of India is the supreme law of the land, and all authorities (Union and State Governments) must operate within the boundaries set by it. If there is any conflict between the law passed by Parliament and a law passed by a State Legislature, the Union law prevails, especially when it involves matters of national importance.
iv. Bicameral Legislature
India has a bicameral legislature, meaning it consists of two houses: the Lok Sabha (House of the People) and the Rajya Sabha (Council of States). The Rajya Sabha represents the States, ensuring their participation in the law-making process at the national level.
v. Independent Judiciary
India has an independent judiciary that ensures that laws made by the Union or the States conform to the Constitution. The Judiciary has the power of judicial review, allowing it to examine the constitutional validity of laws and policies of both the Union and State Governments.
3. Key Features of Federalism in India (Continued)
vi. Single Constitution
Unlike many federal countries, where both the central and state governments have separate Constitutions, India has a single Constitution that governs both the Union and State Governments. This ensures uniformity and consistency across the country.
vii. Strong Central Government
Although India is a federal system, the central government has been granted more power than the states. The Union Government can legislate on a wide range of issues, including those that are not explicitly mentioned in the Constitution, through the Residuary Powers (powers over matters not mentioned in any of the three lists).
This centralization is aimed at ensuring the unity and integrity of India, especially in a country with such a diverse population.
viii. Emergency Provisions
The emergency provisions in the Constitution allow the central government to assume greater powers during times of national emergency. These provisions give the Union Government more authority over the states, as seen during times of war, external aggression, or internal disturbances. This reflects the unitary bias in India’s federal system.
- National Emergency (Article 352): The central government can take over governance during times of war or external aggression.
- State Emergency (Article 356): The President can dissolve the state government and assume direct control over the state in case of failure to comply with constitutional duties.
- Financial Emergency (Article 360): The central government can take control of state finances in case of a threat to national financial stability.
4. Federalism and the States in India
i. Relationship between the Union and States
While the Union Government holds significant powers, the states also have their own set of responsibilities. The Constitution grants autonomy to states over several matters, allowing them to legislate and govern on specific issues that concern their own regions. However, the Union Government has overriding authority, especially in times of national crisis.
- Union-State Relations: The division of power is not always clear-cut. In case of a conflict between Union and State law, the Union law prevails.
- Cooperative Federalism: The relationship between the Union and the States is generally cooperative, with regular consultations through mechanisms like the Inter-State Council and Zonal Councils. These bodies help facilitate coordination between the different levels of government.
ii. Role of the President in Federalism
The President of India plays an essential role in maintaining the balance of power between the Union and the States. Some of the President’s powers that affect federalism include:
- Power to dissolve the Lok Sabha: This can be done when the Union Government seeks a fresh mandate from the people.
- Power to promulgate Ordinances: The President can issue ordinances that have the same effect as laws passed by Parliament, especially when Parliament is not in session.
- Discretionary Powers: The President can use his discretion in certain situations, such as in the appointment of the Governor or when using the power of Article 356 (President’s Rule).
5. Challenges to Indian Federalism
i. Unequal Distribution of Power
One of the key challenges of Indian federalism is the unequal distribution of powers between the Union and the States. The Union Government has more significant powers than the States, which can lead to tensions between them, particularly in matters of governance and legislation.
ii. Role of the Union Government in State Affairs
At times, the Union Government uses its powers to intervene in the states’ internal matters, especially when the state government is perceived to be violating the Constitution or when the President’s Rule is imposed under Article 356. This has led to debates about the centralization of power in India.
iii. Demand for Greater Autonomy
Several states in India have demanded greater autonomy to handle their own affairs without central interference. The creation of states like Telangana (2014) and earlier the demand for separate states like Gorkhaland (West Bengal), Vidarbha (Maharashtra), and others reflect the desire for autonomy and self-governance.
iv. Linguistic and Regional Diversity
India’s vast linguistic, cultural, and ethnic diversity can sometimes challenge the concept of unity in diversity. Regional disparities, such as economic imbalances and the underdevelopment of some states, can also exacerbate tensions in the federal system.
6. Federal Features of the Indian Constitution
India’s federal structure is shaped by a variety of factors that balance both centralization and decentralization:
- Single Constitution: There is one Constitution for both the Union and States.
- Division of Powers: The powers are divided into three lists (Union, State, and Concurrent).
- Strong Central Government: The Union has more powers, particularly in emergencies.
- Independent Judiciary: The judiciary has the power of judicial review, ensuring that the laws passed by both Union and States are constitutional.
- Bicameral Legislature: The Rajya Sabha (Council of States) represents the states in the Union Legislature, ensuring that their interests are considered.
- Representation of States: States have representation in the Union Executive through the Governor, who is appointed by the President.
7. Conclusion
Federalism in India is a unique system, balancing unity and diversity. While the Constitution of India creates a federal structure, it includes provisions that allow the Union Government to be strong in maintaining national unity and addressing issues that transcend regional boundaries. The system provides for cooperation between the Union and the States, though it also faces challenges in the form of regional demands for greater autonomy and conflicts in the distribution of powers.
Why Choose CBSEJanta.com for Class 11 Political Science?
- Free NCERT Solutions: Access detailed, easy-to-understand answers to all questions from your textbook.
- Interactive Chapter Summaries: Quickly grasp the essence of each chapter with our concise summaries.
- Practice Papers & Sample Questions: Test your knowledge and ensure you’re fully prepared for exams.
- Expert Tips for Exam Success: Discover strategies for crafting high-quality answers and managing your exam time effectively.
- Comprehensive Analysis: Dive deep into crucial political concepts for a thorough understanding of each topic.
Download the CBSEJanta App NOW!
Get instant access to Class 11 History solutions, summaries, and practice tests directly on your phone. Enhance your History studies with CBSEJanta.com—your ultimate study companion!
Stay ahead in your History class with CBSEJanta.com and make learning both engaging and effective!